How should Tanzania use its natural gas? Citizens’ views from a nationwide deliberative poll
Loading...
Date
2017
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
International Initiative for Impact Evaluation
Abstract
Public opinion is often treated as an obstacle to good governance in resource-rich
developing countries, associated with populist policies and excess consumption. Can
ordinary citizens in a low-income democracy make meaningful judgements about complex resource management issues? We report on a nationwide poll of voting-age adults in Tanzania, where large natural gas reserves were recently discovered. Results from a randomized experiment within our nationwide polling sample show that the combination of information and extended, structured, and participatory deliberation generated (i) a measurable increase in knowledge of the gas sector; (ii) increased support for sale of natural gas and reduced support for energy subsidies; (iii) no change in support for saving versus spending gas revenues; (iv) a sharp decline in support for direct cash distribution of resource rents to citizens; (v) increased support for spending on social services as opposed to infrastructure; and (vi) a marginally significant increase in support for transparency and oversight measures. Democratic deliberation appears to be the key to these changes; the information treatment alone produced no significant impacts, and impacts did not spill over onto individuals in the same community who did not participate in deliberation. As part of a second-order experiment to measure public accountability, we provided the citizens’ polling results to elites before polling them on a subset of the same questions. Our analysis indicates that elites demonstrate a tendency to align their views with public opinion on most major issues.
Description
Keywords
Citation
Birdsall, N., Fishkin, J., Haqqi, F., Kinyondo, A., Moyo, M., Richmond, J., and Sandefur, J. (2017). “How should Tanzania use its natural gas? Citizens’ views from a nationwide deliberative poll”. International Initiative for Impact Evaluation. Washington, DC.